top of page

When “Strong” Isn’t Enough: College Admissions Strategy for High-Achieving Students

  • Writer: Ronnie Bernier Burnett
    Ronnie Bernier Burnett
  • Sep 25
  • 3 min read

I just returned from NACAC (National Association for College Admission Counseling), and one theme followed me from the convention center hallways to the session rooms: families of high-achieving students are puzzled, and often frustrated, by why their “strong” candidate isn’t breaking through.

NACAC conference sign at entrance — where experts discussed college admissions strategy for high-achieving students.

It’s a story I hear often as an admissions strategist and a mom:


“My child has a 4.8 GPA, a 1580 SAT, every award under the sun—how could they not get in?”

At one time, that résumé alone might have been enough. But the landscape has shifted. Today, the “standard strong” applicant is no longer rare, it's the most common profile in the pool.


The “Standard Strong” Trap in College Admissions


The NACAC panel named it plainly:


“Standard strong applicants—high grades, top test scores, leadership—are the most overrepresented group in the global pool.”

These students are high-achieving in every measurable way. They are captains, presidents, honor society leaders. But in today's admissions landscape they don’t bring a clear “hook.”


Parents often struggle here. They compare today’s reality to their own admissions experience 20 years ago, when being strong, on paper, was enough.


As the panel put it:


“Families compare today’s process to their own admissions 20 years ago—but the landscape is completely different.”

And that’s the crux: today’s applicant pool is broader, deeper, and more global than ever before. Strong gets you in the pile, but it doesn’t guarantee you’ll be pulled out of it.


Premature Completion Syndrome: Why Drafts Matter


One of the session’s most memorable phrases was “Premature Completion Syndrome.”


“Students think they’re done when the words hit the page. But those early drafts often miss the critical reflection and insight that differentiate candidates.” — NACAC panel

It’s the trap of stopping too soon. The first essay draft looks fine, polished even, but lacks the depth that only comes with time, reflection, and revision.


For standard strong applicants, this is particularly risky. Without a hook, every single component of the file has to work harder. And surface-level essays are a death knell.


“For strong-but-standard applicants, every element matters.” — NACAC panel

Impact Over Accomplishment in Admissions Strategy


Another theme that resonated: the difference between accomplishments and impact.


Students (and parents) often equate a long list of titles, trophies, and test scores with admissions success. But admissions officers are asking a different set of questions:


  • How did this student shape their community?

  • How did they influence their peers?

  • What lasting impact will they carry forward to our campus?


As the panel reminded us:


“We’re looking for more than personal achievement. We want to see the impact students have had on others.”

Accomplishments get noticed. Impact gets remembered.


Fit Requires Self-Exploration in College Choice


Perhaps the most underappreciated step for strong students is the hardest: true self-exploration.


One panelist shared an example:


“A sheltered student applying to Columbia in New York City needs to ask: am I ready for this environment?”

This is where strategy and authenticity meet. Students must look inward as much as outward. They need to define the “DNA strands” of their top-choice schools and ask whether those align with their own readiness and goals.


As I’ve said on Admissions Beat:


“Admissions officers have effective crap detectors. Authenticity shows through writing. The time and deliberation a student invests is visible on the page.”

When supplements merely repeat website copy or drop a school’s name without reflection, they fall flat. What moves an application forward is honest alignment.


The Waitlist Reality for Strong Students


For many strong students, the outcome at selective schools isn’t rejection, it’s the waitlist. And while that can feel like hope, the truth is more sobering.


“Admissions offices are more selective at this stage. Additional materials face enhanced scrutiny.” — NACAC panel

The waitlist is not a holding pen—it’s a final round of evaluation. Only the most precise and authentic updates have a chance to move the needle. Families often underestimate just how high the bar is.


What Families Can Take Away


If your student is a “standard strong” candidate, this isn’t a cause for despair. It’s a call to shift strategy.


The solution isn’t piling on another AP course or another leadership title. It’s about cultivating presence—through story, impact, and authentic fit.


  • Treat supplements as seriously as the personal statement.

  • Prioritize impact over accomplishment.

  • Recognize that every draft is a beginning, not an end.

  • Be honest about fit before hitting submit.

  • Approach waitlists with clear eyes and careful strategy.


Because in the end, selective college admissions isn’t about perfection on paper. It’s about presence, impact, and fit.


“Strong gets you in the door. Being intentional, authentic, and impactful gets you admitted.”


ree

bottom of page